Evans v. Evans [1] SummaryThreat Type: LawsuitDate: 03/02/2007Status: PendingDisposition: Injunction DeniedInjunction IssuedLocation: California Verdict or Settlement Amount: N/ALegal Claims: Breach of ContractDefamationHarassmentPublication of Private Facts In March 2007, Thomas Evans, a deputy sheriff in the San Diego County Sheriff's Department, sued his former wife, Linda Evans, and her mother, Shirley Preddy, for defamation, harassment, invasion of privacy, and other claims. After Thomas and Linda Evans divorced in... read full description PartiesParty Receiving Legal Threat: Linda A. Evans; Shirley PreddyType of Party: IndividualType of Party: IndividualLocation of Party: CaliforniaLocation of Party: CaliforniaLegal Counsel: Harrison Patterson & O'Connor; Harry W. HarrisonLegal Counsel: Linda A. Evans (Pro Se) Description In March 2007, Thomas Evans, a deputy sheriff in the San Diego County Sheriff's Department, sued his former wife, Linda Evans, and her mother, Shirley Preddy, for defamation, harassment, invasion of privacy, and other claims. After Thomas and Linda Evans divorced in 2002, they engaged in a bitter dispute in family court over custody of their child, child support, and other issues. Thomas filed a separate lawsuit in California court after Linda and her mother allegedly posted false statements about him on various Internet websites and filed two written complaints with his employer. Thomas also alleged that Linda and Preddy published information from his medical and financial records on the Internet. The trial court granted Thomas a preliminary injunction that prohibited Linda and Preddy from: (1) publishing "false and defamatory statements" about Thomas on the Internet; (2) publishing "confidential personal information" about Thomas on the Internet; and (3) contacting Thomas's employer regarding Thomas except to call 911 to report criminal conduct. Linda appealed, and the appellate court reversed the ruling of the district court. It held that the preliminary injunction was an unconstitutional prior restraint on speech, and that it was unconstitutionally vague and overbroad. The court remanded the case to the district court for further proceedings. On the issue of Linda's alleged publication of Thomas's private information, the appellate court instructed the lower court to identify precisely what information Thomas seeks to protect and to balance his privacy rights (and the safety issues involved in disclosing personal information about a police officer) against the free-speech interests in publication. Sometime before the appellate court ruled on the appeal, Thomas dismissed Preddy from the case, leaving Linda as the only defendant. Related Links: CMLP: Evans v. Evans: Appellate Court Throws Out Prior Restraint [2] DetailsContent Type: TextPublication Medium: WebsiteSubject Area: DefamationPublication of Private FactsPrior Restraints Court Information & DocumentsJurisdiction: CaliforniaSource of Law: CaliforniaCourt Name: California Superior Court, San Diego County; Court of Appeals, Fourth District, CaliforniaCourt Type: StateCase Number: GIC881162 (trial level); No. D051144 (appellate level)Relevant Documents: 2008-05-12-Evans v. Evans Appellate Decision.pdf [3] 2007-09-24-Linda Brief.pdf [4] 2007-11-20-Evans brief.pdf [5] CMLP Information (Private)CMLP Notes: AVM 6/12/09 - I checked the court docket, it does not indicate the resolution of the remaining counts against Ms. Evans. Can be found here court docket [6] in case the documents are ever microfilmed. Checked Westlaw, no update to the docket Appellate briefs are on WL and I uploaded them as well